Request that you correct a serious factual error
Reader comment on item: Emerson Exposes Radical Ties of State Department Outreach Partners

Submitted by Corey Saylor, Aug 13, 2008 15:23

Mr. Emerson:

I am writing to request that you correct a serious factual error in your July 31, 2008, testimony before the United States House of Representatives Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittee on Terrorism, Nonproliferation and Trade.

While you are entitled to your opinion, characterizing my statement to Ambassador Hughes as "a rationalization of the violent attacks against the U.S." is a creative leap rivaling the imagination of the greatest authors of fiction.

In reality, I concur fully with the August 2005 anti-terror fatwa endorsed by CAIR and many other Muslims groups, which reads in part: "Targeting civilians' life and property through suicide bombings or any other method of attack is haram – or forbidden - and those who commit these barbaric acts are criminals, not ‘martyrs...' Further, I concur with an October 4, 2003 CAIR news release that describes a suicide bombing in a Haifa restaurant that killed at least 19 people, including three children as "particularly loathsome."

On pg. 25 of your testimony, you assert: "Saylor stated that Bin Laden ‘sought to exploit legitimate Muslim grievances.' [Ambassador Karen] Hughes did not challenge Saylor's rationalization of the violent attacks against the U.S. by referring to the motivations of blood thirsty terrorists as ‘legitimate Muslim grievances.' The only way these Muslim grievances could be considered ‘legitimate' would be if one equated the failure of the U.S. to become a Muslim country as ‘legitimate.'"

Callously inserting such patently false allegations into your testimony diminishes the integrity of the record of the U.S. Congress.

It is well known that Al-Qaeda and other anti-American forces exploit Israel's occupation of Palestinian territory to further their own twisted and un-Islamic agenda. As recently as June 3, 2008, Secretary of State Rice acknowledged the occupation when speaking to attendees of an American Israel Public Affairs Committee banquet, stating: "…the only responsible policy is to work with decent Palestinians who want and should be able to end the occupation that began in 1967…."

It is also well-established that many in the Muslim world perceive America's role in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as favoring Israel.

My assertion, which I believe to be fully in America's national security interest, is that, if our nation takes a leading role in guiding the Israelis and Palestinians to finalizing a just and lasting peace, this will deprive Al-Qaeda and other anti-American forces of a tool they use to bring people into their murderous mindset: the allegation that Americans do not care about Palestinian suffering.

The last line of your above quoted testimony statement is obscure, but seems to question my allegiance to my nation and its Constitution.

I refer you to an op-ed I authored for July 4, 2005 in which I wrote:

"I and many other Americans are deeply disturbed by events in Iraq, by reports of torture and desecration of the Quran in Guantanamo Bay, by Patriot Act abuses, by the rising tide of anti-Muslim rhetoric in our society, and by domestic and international policies that seem to create more problems than they solve.

"But my love for America is not diminished because it is sometimes flawed. I love my nation because, despite its flaws, the majority of its people remain committed to tolerance and respect for one another, whatever their faith or viewpoint.

"After the 9/11 attacks, my neighbors could have turned their anger on me as a Muslim. They did not. They came to me and offered both support and their horror that someone would twist my faith in such an evil manner.

"But of greatest inspiration to me are the words written in 1998 by a Muslim 10th grader living in California. Following the attack on the USS Cole, he wrote a letter to Osama bin Laden. In that letter he wrote: ‘If you are keen to murder Americans, kill us before you kill non-Muslim Americans. Bomb our mosques and Islamic Centers. We are Americans as much as others.'"

Your prompt action in issuing a public retraction and apology on this issue is appreciated. I am BCC'ing appropriate congressional staff to ensure that they are aware of your error.


Sincerely,

Corey P. Saylor
National Legislative Director
Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR)


Note: IPT will moderate reader comments. We reserve the right to edit or remove any comment we determine to be inappropriate. This includes, but is not limited to, comments that include swearing, name calling, or offensive language involving race, religion or ethnicity. All comments must include an email address for verification.

  • Submit a comment on this item
  • More Reader Comments

    Title By Date

    CAIR=Terrorist Operative [119 words]

    SFC MAC 

    Aug 19, 2008 08:41

    An unobscure comment [138 words]

    Brian T 

    Aug 16, 2008 21:09

    "Have some more money" [28 words]

     

    Aug 16, 2008 13:16

    My response to Corey Saylor [1021 words]

    Steven Emerson 

    Aug 13, 2008 15:24

    ⇒ Request that you correct a serious factual error [691 words]

    Corey Saylor 

    Aug 13, 2008 15:23

    Listen to Steven! [75 words]

    Kurt 

    Aug 7, 2008 16:16

    State Dept.'s Outreach [131 words]

    A. Lopez 

    Aug 4, 2008 03:04

    Congress should investigate U.S. funding of the Palestinian Authority [324 words]

    Yael 

    Aug 2, 2008 09:09

    Thank you [138 words]

    PRCS 

    Aug 2, 2008 01:28

    ISN'T THE STATE DEPT..... [28 words]

     

    Aug 1, 2008 20:49

    Does the State dept, FBI etc give a damn?! [80 words]

    number 6 

    Aug 1, 2008 17:12

    The stupidity of American bureaucrats [51 words]

    Muslims Against Sharia 

    Aug 1, 2008 14:40

    how does this happen? [62 words]

    Brent 

    Aug 1, 2008 12:05

      America Alone [57 words]

    Lisa 

    Aug 4, 2008 16:28

    Comment on Emerson Exposes Radical Ties of State Department Outreach Partners

    Mark my comment as a response to Request that you correct a serious factual error by Corey Saylor

    Email me if someone replies to my comment

    Note: IPT will moderate reader comments. We reserve the right to edit or remove any comment we determine to be inappropriate. This includes, but is not limited to, comments that include swearing, name calling, or offensive language involving race, religion or ethnicity. All comments must include an email address for verification.

    Click here to see the top 25 recent comments.